The Pittsburgh Pirates have made headlines by firing manager Derek Shelton just 38 games into the 2025 season, a decision that underscores the team’s ongoing struggles. With a dismal record of 12-26 and sitting ten games behind in the NL Central, it was clear a change was needed. The Pirates have now appointed bench coach Don Kelly as the new manager, signaling a fresh direction as the team looks to rebuild for the future. Shelton’s tumultuous tenure, which concluded with a 306-440 record, was marked by three last-place finishes and a stark absence from the postseason since 2015. As owner Bob Nutting alluded in his statement about the Pirates’ managerial change, the organization must act with urgency to turn things around, especially with the team’s recent losing streak highlighting the need for significant improvements ahead of the remainder of the Pirates’ 2025 season.
This recent shift in leadership for the Pittsburgh-based baseball team has raised eyebrows and sparked discussions among fans and analysts alike. Following the recent challenges that have plagued this storied franchise, the move to let go of Shelton and replace him with Kelly is seen as a pivotal moment as they look toward revitalizing the team’s performance. With the current struggles encapsulated by a subpar opening to the Pirates’ 2025 campaign, the management’s decision reflects a deeper need for a transformative approach. Observers are questioning the potential impact of this change, particularly given the remarks from general manager Ben Cherington regarding the necessity for fresh perspectives. As the team prepares for upcoming games, the focus now shifts to whether this new managerial era can finally breathe life back into the Pirates’ roster.
Pittsburgh Pirates Fire Derek Shelton: What Went Wrong?
The Pittsburgh Pirates have made a significant decision by firing manager Derek Shelton after just 38 games into the 2025 season. This decision followed a horrific start, with the team sitting at a dismal 12-26 and trailing ten games in the NL Central. Shelton’s tenure, characterized by three last-place finishes and an alarming win percentage of .410, ultimately pointed to an unsustainable situation. Despite his hard work and dedication, which General Manager Ben Cherington recognized in his statement, the results on the field did not reflect the effort that was put in by both players and staff. The team has also experienced a troubling streak, losing seven consecutive games and managing only one win in their past ten outings, putting pressure on the organization to take immediate action to turn things around.
This firing is not merely a reaction to the team’s poor performance; it’s indicative of larger systemic issues within the Pirates organization. Reflecting on the past seasons, it is clear that Derek Shelton inherited a struggling franchise, and while he managed to maintain the clubhouse environment, results were ultimately lacking. Moreover, with little postseason success since 2015 and a declining payroll compared to previous years, it raises questions about whether Shelton was ever given the necessary resources to truly succeed. The incoming manager, Don Kelly, has his work cut out for him as he tries to navigate these challenges almost immediately.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was Derek Shelton fired as the manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates?
Derek Shelton was fired as the manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates after a disappointing start to the 2025 season, where the team recorded just 12 wins against 26 losses, placing them significantly behind in the NL Central and extending their losing streak to seven games. His overall record of 306-440 during his tenure included three last-place finishes and no postseason appearances, leading to the management’s decision for a change.
Who has been appointed as the new manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates?
Following the firing of Derek Shelton, the Pittsburgh Pirates appointed bench coach Don Kelly as the new manager. This change aims to bring a fresh perspective and hopefully improve the team’s fortunes in the wake of a challenging start to the 2025 season.
What is the current record of the Pittsburgh Pirates in the 2025 season?
As of now, the Pittsburgh Pirates have started the 2025 season with a record of 12 wins and 26 losses, which places them 10 games behind in the NL Central.
What did Ben Cherington say about Derek Shelton’s firing?
Ben Cherington, the general manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates, expressed that Derek Shelton worked incredibly hard during his five-plus years with the team. He reflected on Shelton’s intelligence and leadership qualities while also noting that a change was necessary to move forward.
What challenges does the Pittsburgh Pirates face beyond the managerial change?
The Pittsburgh Pirates face more significant challenges beyond the managerial change, mainly stemming from deeper institutional issues within the organization. Analysts suggest that simply switching managers may not lead to meaningful change without greater investment in the team’s development and operations.
How long has it been since the Pittsburgh Pirates made a postseason appearance?
The Pittsburgh Pirates have not made a postseason appearance since 2015 when they lost in the National League wildcard game to the Chicago Cubs. Since then, the team has struggled, marked by multiple last-place finishes and a lack of competitive success.
What impact does ownership have on the future of the Pittsburgh Pirates?
Ownership, particularly under Bob Nutting, has been a focal point in discussions regarding the Pittsburgh Pirates’ future. Analysts argue that genuine investment and commitment to improving the team’s performance are crucial for a turnaround, suggesting that without it, any changes in management will not be sufficient to address the organization’s long-term struggles.
| Key Points |
|---|
| The Pittsburgh Pirates have fired manager Derek Shelton after 38 games into the 2025 season. |
| Don Kelly, the former bench coach, has been appointed as the new manager. |
| The team holds a record of 12-26, sitting 10 games behind in the NL Central. |
| The Pirates are currently on a seven-game losing streak. |
| Shelton’s overall record with the Pirates was 306-440 with no postseason appearances. |
| Team owner Bob Nutting emphasized the need for urgency in addressing team problems. |
| Analysts believe greater changes are needed beyond managerial alteration. |
| General manager Ben Cherington expressed respect for Shelton but acknowledged a change was necessary. |
Summary
The Pittsburgh Pirates have made a significant change by firing manager Derek Shelton after a disappointing start to the 2025 season. With a record of 12-26, the team currently struggles in the NL Central, and the decision to appoint Don Kelly as the new manager reflects a desperate need for a turnaround. Despite Shelton’s long tenure, his leadership did not yield the desired results, and many analysts argue that deeper organizational changes are essential for revitalizing the Pirates’ fortunes. As the team looks to correct its trajectory, the emphasis on investment and strategic overhaul will be crucial in the coming months.